Buddhism, Christianity and the question of creation: karmic by Perry Schmidt-Leukel

By Perry Schmidt-Leukel

Is the area created by way of a divine writer? Or is it the consistent fabricated from karmic forces? the difficulty of construction used to be on the center of the vintage controversies among Buddhism and Hindu Theism. nowa days, it may be discovered on the centre of many polemical debates among Buddhism and Christianity. is that this the primary barrier that separates Buddhism from Christianity and different theistic religions? The contributions to half One discover many of the elements of conventional and modern Buddhist objections opposed to the assumption of a divine author in addition to Christian chances to satisfy the Buddhist critique. half asks for the aptitude fact on each side and indicates a stunning manner that the barrier could be conquer. This opens a brand new around of philosophical and theological discussion among those significant traditions with difficult insights for either.

Show description

Read or Download Buddhism, Christianity and the question of creation: karmic or divine? PDF

Similar religious studies & reference books

Prayer Has Spoiled Everything: Possession, Power, and Identity in an Islamic Town of Niger (Body, Commodity, Text)

Bori, within the Mawri society of Niger, are mischievous and invisible beings that populate the bush. Bori is additionally the perform of taming those wild forces within the context of ownership ceremonies. In Prayer Has Spoiled every thing Adeline Masquelier deals an account of ways this phenomenon intervenes—sometimes subtly, occasionally dramatically—in human lives, supplying a consistently renewed resource of which means for Mawri peasants faced with cultural contradictions and socio-economic marginalization.

The Gauntlet: A Challenge to the Myth of Progress

Subtitled "A problem to the parable of Progress," this assortment contains decisions from outdated Worlds for brand new, Post-Industrialism, in the direction of a Christian Sociology, and potential and Ends. This first-ever anthology of Penty's works offers a compelling imaginative and prescient either one of what is wrong with the area and of what sort of socio-economic order might aid to make it correct.

Pragmatic Encroachment, Religious Belief, and Practice

Attractive a number of fresh and significant discussions within the mainstream epistemological literature surrounding 'pragmatic encroachment', the amount asks, among others, the query: Do the excessive stakes fascinated by accepting or rejecting trust in God bring up the factors for wisdom that God exists?

Additional info for Buddhism, Christianity and the question of creation: karmic or divine?

Sample text

30 God as cause is also a target of Bhavya, a major polemic of this school,3! as well as of the didactic poet Santideva. 32 Similarly, the arguments derived from theodicy are presented here in many variations, but also an argument from causality is elaborated which refutes God on the grounds that as he is only one - that is, single and permanent - it cannot be explained how he could be active at all. The historical origin and development of this argument is still unclear to me. :34 (a) If Isvara is the cause of everything, then he must create everything at once (since efficiency implies immediate causation); (b) if he requires help, then he is not the sole cause; (c) if he is undifferentiated and eternal, so must be his effects (since effect must resemble cause); (d) since effects are known to be impermanent, their alleged permanent cause has no more 'existence' than other inexistent entities.

56-142. Cf. , pp. 97-101. Hindu Doctrines of Creation and Buddhist Critiques 31 in the form of momentariness. 47 They therefore argue against the possibility of any causal interaction between a permanent factor and impermanent entities: not only because it is impossible, but also because it is unnecessary, meaningless. Moreover, Hindu concepts of a permanent creating factor are modelled on an analogy to human activity: change in everything thus also presupposes a planning consciousness. 48 Theologically speaking, it may then be worth considering the questions of whether the focus on continuity and the human analogy of causal activity - both referring to the finite realm - are necessary to a discourse on God.

The Blissful' - the world created by the Buddha Amitiibha, but the Mahayana literature is replete with references to the creation of other pure fields, to the point where the ritual prediction of a bodhisattva's future attainment of buddhahood comes to include the naming of his or her future pure land as part of the formula. Now I think it important to bring up the notion of pure lands in this discussion for two reasons: (1) it paints a less tragic picture of the world than we find in other forms of Buddhist literature.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.56 of 5 – based on 45 votes